Title : Can state law require that churches permit women to breastfeed openly — with no covering — in the congregation during a service?
link : Can state law require that churches permit women to breastfeed openly — with no covering — in the congregation during a service?
Can state law require that churches permit women to breastfeed openly — with no covering — in the congregation during a service?
Virginia has a law that gives women a right to breastfeed wherever they are "lawfully present." I can see why laws like this get passed, and I feel sympathy for this woman who was embarrassed to be told she can't breastfeed in the manner she presumably believed was okay (especially after the government has purported to enshrine this right in the law)...But I think privately owned places — especially religious institutions — should be allowed to impose their own standards of modesty. There's a big difference between being deprived of the freedom to breastfeed wherever you are and being required to drape a light cloth over the exposed breast.
This WaPo report on the subject completely takes the perspective of the woman and makes the churchgoers seem prudish and ignorant of the law:
A woman promptly asked the Dumfries mother to decamp to a private room, she said. Peguero declined and was later told that the church does not allow breast-feeding without a cover because it could make men, teenagers or new churchgoers “uncomfortable,” she said. One woman told her the sermon was being live-streamed and that she would not want Peguero to be seen breast-feeding....The woman, Annie Peguero, is described as "an attorney" and "42-year-old personal trainer and fitness and nutrition specialist" and — these are her words — a “hippie mama."
It is also a legally protected right in Virginia, where the legislature passed a 2015 law that says women have a right to breast-feed anywhere they have a legal right to be....
It seems to me that churches — and other religious organizations — have rules about how covered up you need to be in the building or during a service. And the last time I looked, Virginia has a Religious Freedom Preservation Act, § 57-2.02:
No government entity shall substantially burden a person's free exercise of religion even if the burden results from a rule of general applicability unless it demonstrates that application of the burden to the person is (i) essential to further a compelling governmental interest and (ii) the least restrictive means of furthering that compelling governmental interest.Quite aside from whether Peguero has a statutory right to breastfeed uncovered in church (and I don't think she does), as a matter of etiquette and caring for others, she should have willingly covered her breast as soon as she noticed the exposure distracted or bothered anybody.
Here's the highest-rated comment at WaPo:
As someone who has lived all over the world, I can assure you America is the only place on earth where people get hysterical seeing mothers breastfeed their babies.Here's the second-highest-rated:
Exactly what is it about a breast that has you guys upset? It is not a sex organ. It was made for women to feed their babies. The fact that it has been sexualized by men does not make it a sex organ.
I get the whole "it's natural" thing, but have a little consideration for those around you. You still cannot walk around nude freely in our society. And, it does make people uncomfortable ... which is also "natural". Use a blanket or step out of the room. Why is that such a huge deal?
Thus Article Can state law require that churches permit women to breastfeed openly — with no covering — in the congregation during a service?
That's an article Can state law require that churches permit women to breastfeed openly — with no covering — in the congregation during a service? This time, hopefully can give benefits to all of you. well, see you in posting other articles.
You are now reading the article Can state law require that churches permit women to breastfeed openly — with no covering — in the congregation during a service? with the link address https://infotodays1.blogspot.com/2017/04/can-state-law-require-that-churches.html
0 Response to "Can state law require that churches permit women to breastfeed openly — with no covering — in the congregation during a service?"
Post a Comment